Retaining Agricultural Workers Through Strategic Engagement

Behind every harvest is a human story of effort, resilience, and often, quiet frustration. 
These challenges extend beyond the physical rigors of agricultural work; they often stem from a lack of connection between workers and the broader purpose of their roles (Black & Arruda, 2021; Luo & Escalante, 2017; O'Shaughnessy et al., 2023; Reid & Schenker, 2016). Strategic engagement provides a powerful tool to address this. Agricultural employers can improve retention and morale by meaningfully involving workers in decision-making, aligning their roles with the farm's mission, and fostering clear communication and shared ownership.

This article examines strategic engagement in the agricultural workforce, its importance, and how simple, effective practices can strengthen workers' commitment to their roles and the farm's future.

What Is Strategic Engagement? 

Strategic engagement refers to structured efforts that connect employees meaningfully to the goals and values of the workplace. It involves practices like inviting workers to participate in planning decisions, setting shared goals, providing relevant training, and recognizing worker input. When applied consistently, these actions make workers feel respected, empowered, and part of something greater than routine tasks (Muse Marketing Group, 2024). Strategic engagement is essential because it helps employees connect with the organization's mission and feel personally invested in its success. When people understand how their roles support broader goals, they are more motivated, productive, and likely to stay with the organization (CMOE, 2024). This connection reduces turnover and builds a stronger, more committed workforce.

Below, we outlined five actionable strategies that farm owners, farm supervisors, and managers can use to strengthen retention through strategic engagement, building a workforce, and a committed community at the workplace.

Involving Workers in Operational Decisions 

One of the most effective ways to build engagement is to invite workers into decisions that directly impact their jobs. Whether scheduling shifts, selecting equipment, or planning training sessions, giving workers a voice increases their sense of ownership and investment. In a study of H-2A workers, many reported that being included in decisions, especially around time-off policies and training, made them feel more respected and committed to their work (Gallardo et al., 2024).

Setting Clear Expectations and Goals Together 

Clarity builds trust. When farm teams know precisely what is expected of them and have a say in setting those expectations, they are more confident and committed. Tools like written job checklists, SOPs, or visual work boards make goals transparent and allow workers to measure progress. Simple steps like reviewing weekly priorities in team meetings help ensure everyone is aligned and accountable for shared outcomes (Gregorio et al., 2024).

Offering Training That Builds Confidence and Career Vision 

Training is not just about improving productivity; it is about investing in people. Workers feel more motivated when they see opportunities to grow beyond daily tasks. On many farms, offering English classes, machine operation instruction, or even leadership development shows workers that their futures matter. These types of training were ranked nearly as important as bonuses by H-2A workers in recent survey results (Gallardo et al., 2024). 

Recognizing Contributions in Meaningful Ways 

When agricultural workers perceive their efforts as overlooked or undervalued, their level of engagement tends to decline. Strategic engagement includes intentional, formal, and informal recognition of an employee's contributions. While financial incentives such as bonuses for seasonal completion or safety performance are effective, simple, personal gestures can be equally impactful. Expressing appreciation at the end of a shift, acknowledging individual efforts during team meetings, or celebrating milestones at the close of a harvest season can reinforce a sense of belonging and purpose. Such recognition practices have improved morale and fostered greater loyalty among farm workers (Dewi et al., 2024).

Fostering a Culture of Respect and Open Communication 

Respect and two-way communication are key to keeping workers engaged and committed. When employees feel heard and treated fairly, they are more likely to trust their employer and stay long term. Farm owners can support this by sharing tasks fairly, rotating team roles, and acting on worker feedback. Research shows respectful communication improves worker morale, resilience, and loyalty (LaGree et al., 2023). Open and honest conversations help reduce anxiety and build trust (WTW, 2025). On farms, this kind of communication also strengthens teamwork and problem-solving (University of Wisconsin–Madison Division of Extension, 2023).

Conclusion 

Strategic engagement is more than a management practice—it is a commitment to building meaningful relationships with the people who power agriculture. As this article has shown, when workers are included in decisions, given clarity in their roles, supported through training, recognized for their efforts, and treated with respect, they are more likely to stay and to thrive. These are not complex solutions but simple, intentional actions that send a powerful message: "You matter here." By adopting these five strategies, farm employers can go beyond short-term fixes and cultivate a culture of connection, trust, and shared purpose. In doing so, they improve retention and create workplaces where people are proud to contribute. In a sector that depends so intensely on human hands and hearts, rooting workforce practices in engagement is not just good for business, it is essential for the future of farming.

To illustrate these dynamics, we present a hypothetical case study based on farmers' narratives shared during Extension workshops over the past decade. All identifying details have been altered to protect confidentiality. This example highlights how broader industry trends influence the daily experiences of agricultural workers.

Case Study: Building a Committed Workforce at Rolling Hills Produce.  

Background: Rolling Hills Produce is a mid-sized, family-run vegetable farm in southern Pennsylvania. With over 80 acres of diversified crops, a seasonal workforce of 33 employees, and many returning H-2A workers, the farm has long prided itself on quality produce and sustainable practices. However, in recent years, farm owner Rachel Zecker noticed rising turnover, declining morale, and frequent communication breakdowns during peak harvest.

"The work was getting done," Rachel said, "but people looked tired, physically and emotionally. We realized we had to invest in our people, not just our production."

Challenge: Like many agricultural employees, Rolling Hills faced retention issues. Seasonal workers were increasingly difficult to retain from year to year. Exit interviews and informal feedback revealed that employees felt disconnected from the farm's mission and unrecognized for their efforts.

Inspired by training from Penn State Extension and research on agricultural labor engagement, Rachel and her farm supervisor team committed to implementing strategic engagement practices during the upcoming season.

Strategic Engagement in Practice

Involving Workers in Operational Decisions 

Before the season began, Rachel gathered small farm worker focus groups to get feedback on equipment preferences, safety protocols, and work schedules. One H-2A worker, Carlos, suggested adjusting the irrigation schedule to reduce overlap with harvest tasks, which improved workflow efficiency.

“When they listened to me and made that change, I felt like I was part of the farm's brain, not just its hands,” said Carlos.

Setting Clear Expectations and Goals Together 

The farm adopted color-coded task boards and posted daily and weekly goals in English and Spanish. Workers meet briefly each Monday to review goals and identify priorities. Supervisors shared updates during breaks, keeping everyone in the loop.

Workers reported reduced stress and felt "more in control and more prepared" during busy weeks.

Offering Training That Builds Confidence and Career Vision 

Rachel introduced short weekly skills workshops. Topics included tractor operation, pesticide safety, and conversational English. Two workers who completed the sessions were promoted to assistant crew leaders by mid-season.

"For the first time, I thought maybe I could move up, not just work," shared Juana, a second-year worker.

Recognizing Contributions in Ways That Matter 

Beyond a modest performance bonus, the farm began a "Shout-Out Friday" tradition. A different worker was recognized at lunch for their effort, teamwork, or innovation each week. One worker, Tomas, received a certificate and a small gift card for mentoring a new crew member.

"The money helps," Tomas said, "but being seen and appreciated stays with you."

Fostering the Culture of Respect and Open Communication 

Supervisors participated in communication training to improve listening skills and conflict resolution. Suggestion boxes and open-door office hours were introduced. A bilingual liaison helped bridge language gaps and ensure fair treatment during peak season challenges.

Rachel noted, “Respect is the foundation. If people do not feel safe or heard, nothing else works.”

Outcomes: By the end of the season, Rolling Hills Produce reported a 25% increase in returning workers and a noticeable drop in workplace conflicts. Informal surveys showed that over 80% of employees felt more respected, included, and motivated than in previous years.

One worker commented, "I did not just work the land this year. I felt rooted in it."

Lessons Learned: Rolling Hills Produce shows how small, consistent actions can transform agricultural workplaces. Their experience affirms that:

• Worker involvement boosts ownership.
• Clarity builds confidence.
• Training supports long-term vision.
• Recognition affirms value.
• Respect and communication sustain commitment.

Summarizing, the story of Rolling Hills Produce illustrates how farms can shift from workforce challenges to workforce commitment. Strategic engagement is about purposeful leadership and relationships. Rachel said, "When we invest in people, they invest back."

References

Black, N. J., & Arruda, A. G. (2021). Turnover events of animal caretakers and their impact on productivity in swine farms. Preventive Veterinary Medicine, 193, 105418. Doi.org/10.1016/j.prevetmed.2021.105418

CMOE Team. (2024). Why strategy is important for employee engagement and retention. CMOE.

Dewi, A., Apriono, M., Tobing, D., Prajitiasari, E., & Susanto, A. (2024). Human capital culture and firm value in Indonesia's agribusiness: aligning hrm practices with sustainable development goals. South Eastern European Journal of Public Health, 1892-1900. Doi.org/10.70135/seejph.vi.2253

Gallardo, K., Gutiérrez-Li, A., Luckstead, J., Nayga, R. M., Sallato, B., & Yang, W. (2024). H‐2A workers' preferences for job attributes: Evidence from an experiment. Journal of the Agricultural and Applied Economics Association, 3(4), 633–654. Doi.org/10.1002/jaa2.137

Gregorio, L., Piva, S., & Neiverth, R. (2024). Recognition and retention: motivating talent in agribusiness. Scientific Journal of Applied Social and Clinical Science, 4(23), 1-12. Doi.org/10.22533/at.ed.2164232425112

LaGree, D., Houston, B., Duffy, M., & Shin, H. (2023). The effect of respect: Respectful communication at work drives resiliency, engagement, and job satisfaction among early career employees. International Journal of Business Communication, 60(3), 844–864. Doi.org/10.1177/23294884211016529

Luo, T., & Escalante, C. L. (2017). US farm workers: What drives their job retention and work time allocation decisions? The Economic and Labour Relations Review, 28(2), 270–293. Doi.org/10.1177/1035304617703933

Muse Marketing Group. (2024). What is strategic engagement?

O'Shaughnessy, B. R., O'Hagan, A. D., Burke, A., McNamara, J., & O'Connor, S. (2023). The prevalence of farmer burnout: Systematic review and narrative synthesis. Journal of Rural Studies, 99, 232–243. Doi.org/10.1016/j.jrurstud.2022.11.002

Reid, A., & Schenker, M. B. (2016). Hired farm workers in the US: Demographics, work organisation, and services. American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 59(8), 644–655. Doi.org/10.1002/ajim.22613

University of Wisconsin–Madison Division of Extension. (2023). Communication strategies for agriculture professionals.

WTW (Willis Towers Watson). (2025, July). Why two-way employee communication during disruption is critical. WTW Insights: Work and Rewards.