Pennsylvania's Nutrient Management Act (Act 38): Who Is Affected?

Learn how to calculate the animal density of an agricultural operation to determine if it is a Concentrated Animal Operation (CAO) and thereby required to implement an Act 38 nutrient management plan.
Pennsylvania's Nutrient Management Act (Act 38): Who Is Affected? - Articles
Pennsylvania's Nutrient Management Act (Act 38): Who Is Affected?

In spring 1993, the Pennsylvania legislature passed and the governor signed the Nutrient Management Act (Act 6) into law. The regulations implementing this law went into effect in 1997. In 2002 the State Conservation Commission began an effort to revise these regulations. In summer 2005, the Pennsylvania legislature replaced Act 6 with Act 38 as part of the Agriculture, Communities, and Rural Environment (ACRE) initiative. The new regulations, now falling under the new Act 38, were finalized in 2006 and went into effect in October of that year.

These revised regulations include several significant changes in the state's nutrient management program, including changes to who is affected by the regulations. This fact sheet addresses the question "Who is affected (regulated) by this legislation and regulations?"

Concentrated Animal Operations

The act states that "concentrated animal operations" will be required to develop and maintain a nutrient management plan. Concentrated animal operations (CAOs) are defined as agricultural operations where the animal density of all livestock on the farm exceeds 2 animal equivalent units (AEUs) per acre on an annualized basis. This animal density criteria has not changed in the new regulations; however, two significant changes were made. First, the definition now includes all livestock, including nonproduction animals such as horses used for recreation and transportation. Second, an operation with fewer than 8 AEUs is not considered to be a CAO regardless of the animal density.

Animal Equivalent Units

An AEU is 1,000 pounds of live weight of any animal on an annualized basis. Annualized means that if animals are not present on an operation for a whole year, the animal units are adjusted for the proportion of time during the year that animals are present on the operation. The calculation involves determining the number of AEUs of all animals on the farm based on the number of animals and their average weights and then adjusting that for the actual number of days (out of 365) that the animals are on the operation. To determine the number of AEUs on a farm, the following formula can be used for each type of animal and then added together to get the total AEUs on the farm:

AEUs for each type of animal = [average number of animals on a typical day that the animals are there x animal weight (lb) ÷ 1,000] x [number of days the animals are on the operation per year ÷ 365]

Table 1 lists standard animal weights that are used to calculate AEUs. It is strongly suggested that these standard animal weights be used for this calculation. However, if the farmer has records of actual weights of the animals on the farm, these may be used to determine the appropriate animal weight to be used for this calculation if the records are complete enough to justify the use of the nonstandard weights. Note that for growing animals, an average weight for their growth over the year is used. For example, for medium broilers that grow from 0.09 to 5 pounds per animal over the growth cycle, the average weight would calculate to be 2.55 pounds per animal.

Table 1. Standard animal weights used to calculate animal equivalent units to identify concentrated animal operations.
Type of AnimalStandard Weight (lbs)
during Production (range)
Dairy, Holstein/Brown Swiss
Calf: 0-1 yr.420 (90-750)
Heifer: 1-2 yr.1000 (750-1,250)
Cow1,450
Bull1,700
Dairy, Ayrshire/Guernsey
Calf: 0-1 yr.1,200 350 (70-630)
Heifer: 1-2 yr.865 (630-1,100)
Cow1,200
Bull1,600
Dairy, Jersey
Calf: 0-1 yr.275 (50-500)
Heifer: 1-2 yr.675 (500-850)
Cow1000
Bull1,200
Beef
Calf: 0-8 months300 (100-500)
Replacement heifer: 8 months to 1 year500 (300–700)
Finishing: 8-24 months950 (500-1,400)
Replacement heifer: 1–2 years875 (700–1,050)
Cow1,400
Bull1,500
Veal
Calf: 0-20 weeks280 (95-465)
Poultry, Layer
Pullet, white egg: 0–16 weeks1.38 (0.08–2.67)
Pullet, brown egg: 0–16 weeks1.54 (0.08–3.0)
Breeder hen, white egg: 17–70 weeks3.25 (2.7–3.8)
Breeder rooster, white egg: 17–70 weeks4.37 (3.67–5.06)
Breeder hen, brown egg: 17–70 weeks3.55 (2.9–4.2)
Breeder rooster, brown egg: 17–70
weeks
4.78 (4.5–5.06)
White egg: 18-75 weeks3.13 (2.82–3.44)
White egg: 18-90 weeks3.14 (2.82–3.46)
Brown egg: 18-75 weeks3.85 (3.35–4.34)
Brown egg: 18-90 weeks3.85 (3.35–4.34)
Poultry, Broiler
Medium: 0-35 days2.55 (0.09–5.0)
Large: 0-53 days3.55 (0.09–7.0)
Roaster Male: 0-7 weeks4.70 (0.09–9.3)
Roaster Female: 0-9 weeks4.95 (0.09–9.8)
Breeder pullet: 0–20 weeks2.55 (0.09–5.0)
Breeder cockerel: 0–20 weeks3.55 (0.09–7.0)
Breeder hen: 20–65 weeks6.75 (5.0–8.5)
Breeder rooster: 20–65 weeks8.75 (7.0–10.5)
Poultry, Turkey
Tom brooder: 0-6 weeks3.36 (0.22–6.5)
Hen Brooder: 0-6 weeks2.74 (0.22–5.25)
Hen regular: 6–12 weeks11.13 (5.25–17)
Hen heavy: 6–16 weeks14.63 (5.25–24)
Tom: 6–18 weeks25.25 (6.5–44)
Poultry, Duck
Starter: 0–17 days1.36 (0.22–2.5)
Finisher: 17–38 days4.88 (2.5–7.25)
Developer: 0–196 days3.21 (0.22–6.2)
Layer6.85 (6.2–7.5)
Poultry, Game Birds
Guinea, growing: 0-14 weeks1.91 (0.06-3.75)
Guinea, mature3.75
Pheasant, growing: 0-13 weeks1.53 (0.05-3.0)
Pheasant, mature3.0
Chukar, growing: 0-13 weeks0.52 (0.04-1.0)
Chukar, mature1.0
Quail, growing: 0-13 weeks0.26 (0.02-0.5)
Quail, mature0.5
Swine
Nursery pig35 (13-57)
Wean to finish143 (13-273)
Grow finish165 (57-273)
Gestating sow450
Sow and litter470
Boar450
Sheep, Larger Breed
Lamb: 0-1 year95 (10–180)
Ewe225
Ram300
Sheep, Medium Breed
Lamb: 0-1 year80 (10–150)
Ewe175
Ram225
Sheep, Smaller Breed
Lamb: 0-1 year45 (10–80)
Ewe100
Ram125
Goats, Meat
Kid: 0-1 year65 (5–125)
Doe150
Buck200
Goats, Dairy
Kid: 0-1 year45 (5-85)
Doe125
Buck170
Miniature Horses and Miniature Donkeys
Foal: 0-6 months35 (25-45)
Weanling: 6-12 months60 (45-75)
Yearling: 12-24 months100 (75-125)
Two-Year-Old: 24-36 months150 (125-175)
Mature200
Ponies and Donkeys
Foal: 0-6 months65 (30-100)
Weanling: 6-12 months150 (100-200)
Yearling: 12-24 months300 (200-400)
Two-Year-Old: 24-36 months400 (300-500)
Mature600
Light Horses and Mules
Foal: 0-6 months190 (80-300)
Weanling: 6-12 months450 (300-600)
Yearling: 12-24 months700 (600-800)
Two-Year-Old: 24-36 months900 (800-1,000)
Mature1,100
Draft Horses
Foal: 0-6 months360 (120-600)
Weanling: 6-12 months800 (600-1,000)
Yearling: 12-24 months1,150 (1,000-1,3005)
Two-Year-Old: 24-36 months1,450 (1,300-1,600)
Mature1,800
Bison
Calf: 0-1 year275 (50–500)
Yearling: 1–2 years650 (500–800)
Cow1,000
Bull1,600
Deer
Fawn: 0-6 months36 (7-65)
Yearling Doe: 6-18 months95 (65-125)
Yearling Buck: 6-18 months110 (65-155)
Mature Doe145
Mature Buck200
Alpaca
Young80 (15-145)
Mature Female145
Mature Male170
Llama
Cria: 0-1 year75 (25–125)
Yearling: 1-2 years213 (125–300)
Mature350

Acres Suitable for Application of Manure

The acreage number used in the animal density calculation is all acres, owned and rented, that are suitable for the application of manure. This acreage is determined to be those lands that meet the following criteria:

  • Cropland, hay land, or pastureland (owned or rented) that is an integral part of the operation
  • Land that is under the management control of the operator
  • Land that is or will be used for the application of manure from the operation

Farmstead and forestland cannot be included in this calculation as land suitable for manure application.

Animal Density

The number of acres that meet the criteria listed above are then divided into the total AEUs on the farm to determine the overall animal density for the operation. Use the blank worksheet on page 4 to calculate the animal density on your farm.

Concentrated Animal Operations Requirements

A CAO as defined under the original regulations that was in existence on the effective date of the revised regulation (October 1, 2006) should already have an approved nutrient management plan. The following are the new plan submission requirements of CAOs as defined in the revised regulations:

  • A new CAO that comes into existence after the effective date must have an approved plan prior to the commencement of manure operations.
  • An agricultural operation that is planning an expansion that will result in that operation becoming a CAO must have an approved plan prior to the expansion.
  • An agricultural operation that because of loss of land suitable for manure application now meets the criteria for a CAO must submit a nutrient management plan within six months after the date of the loss of land.

Example CAO Calculations

The following is an example of an AEU per acre calculation.

Example Farm Data
Animal Inventory (Average weights taken from Table 1)110 dairy cows @ 1,450-lb average weight each
35 heifers @ 1000-lb average weight each
20 calves @ 420-lb average weight each
15,000 large broilers @ 3.55-lb average weight each
Production PeriodCows = 365 days per year
Broilers = 5 flocks for 57 days each, or 285 days per year
Land InventoryFarmstead = 5 acres
Woodland = 3 acres
Pasture = 4 acres
Cropland, home farm = 60 acres
Cropland, rented farm = 36 acres
Using this example data and the worksheet, the calculation of animal density (AEUs per acre) for this farm would be as follows:
Animal TypeNo. Animalsx Animal Weight (lb)x Prod. Days÷ Factor =AEU
* If this figure is less than 8, then the farm would not be a CAO, regardless of the AEU/acre figure calculated below.
** Includes only cropland, hayland, and pastures; for this example there are 96 acres of cropland/hayland and 4 acres of pasture.
Dairy110x 1,450x 365÷ 365,000 =159.5
Heifers35x 1000x 365÷ 365,000 =35
Calves20x 420x 365÷ 365,000 =8.4
Broilers15,000x 3.55x 285÷ 365,000 =41.6
xx÷ 365,000 =
xx÷ 365,000 =
xx÷ 365,000 =
Total* =244.5
Acres available for manure**÷ 100
AEUs/acre= 2.45

This example farm would be defined as a CAO and would be required to develop and implement an approved nutrient management plan. The animal density criterion is not to be construed as prohibiting development or expansion of agricultural operations that would exceed the criterion. It simply means that these operations will be required to have an approved nutrient management plan. Farms with an animal density higher than 2 AEUs per acre are likely to have more nutrients than can be fully used by the crops grown on the farm. Thus, nutrient management plans for CAOs will often describe on-farm manure utilization and procedures for moving some manure off the farm.

Use this worksheet to determine if your farm is a CAO:
Animal
Type
No.
Animals
x Animal Weight
(lb)
x Prod. Days÷ Factor =AEU
* If the total AEUs on the farm is less than 8, the farm is not a CAO, regardless of the animal density.
** Farms with an animal density of greater than 2 AEUs per acre are defined as CAOs.
xx÷ 365,000 =
xx÷ 365,000 =
xx÷ 365,000 =
xx÷ 365,000 =
xx÷ 365,000 =
xx÷ 365,000 =
xx÷ 365,000 =
Total* =
Acres available for manure**÷
Animal density: AEUs/acre=

Other Required Plans

Farms receiving financial or technical assistance from different federal, state, local, or private funding sources may also be required to have a nutrient management plan. Any farm that violates the Clean Streams Law may also be required to develop a nutrient management plan.

Voluntary Plans

Farms with fewer than 2 AEUs per acre and farms with fewer than a total of 8 AEUs on the operation are encouraged to voluntarily develop nutrient management plans. Nutrient management plans, whether required or voluntary, can improve farm profits, help protect the environment, provide some protection from liability, and enhance the image with the general public of agriculture as a good steward of our natural resources.

For More Information

For more information, contact the Penn State Extension office in your county or your local conservation district. For a summary of the Nutrient Management Act and regulations, see Penn State's Nutrient Management Legislation in Pennsylvania: A Summary of the 2006 Regulations, which is available from your local Penn State Extension office.

Prepared by Douglas Beegle, Distinguished Professor of Agronomy, and Jerry Martin, senior extension associate, in cooperation with and with funding from the Pennsylvania State Conservation Commission