Articles

Does Residue Incorporation Improve Its Nutrient Value?

We show that incorporation of crop residues does not improve soil fertility while it can increase nutrient losses through erosion.
Updated:
November 3, 2026

Crop residue left after harvest contains large amounts of nutrients, while it also protects soil from erosion, improves infiltration by reducing the sealing of the soil surface and slowing down runoff, and provides food and habitat for soil organisms. Hopefully farmers and advisors are aware of the importance of residue cover over the wintertime. However, some experts are advising that crop residue be incorporated into the soil to obtain its maximum nutrient value, which would compromise many of its soil protection benefits. Let us review the evidence for this recommendation using corn as our example. 

The ratio between corn grain and stover (leaves, stems, cobs) is about 1:1 (on dry-matter basis). So for every 42 bu/A corn grain (at 15.5% moisture) you get one ton of oven-dry residue, containing approximately 16 lbs of N, 6 lbs of P2O5, and 30 lbs of K2O (USDA-NRCS, 2013). If your yield is 210 bu/A, the stover contains about 80 lbs N, 30 lbs P2O5, and 150 lbs K2O. The question is: does incorporation improve the nutrient return of stover? 

This may depend on the type of nutrient. Nitrogen and phosphorus are mostly present in organic form in the plant: nitrogen predominantly as proteins, amino acids, and structural plant tissues, and phosphorus is a core component of ATP and ADP, DNA and RNA, and of cell membranes. Potassium, on the other hand, is mostly present as cations in the plant. These plant nutrients are all predominantly absorbed in anion or cation form by plant roots, and soil organisms are therefore needed to convert organic N and P into usable forms. Larger organisms are needed to chop up plant residues while microbes convert the organic compounds into cations/anions. Potassium, on the other hand, is already in the plant cells in cation form and when the plant dies and cell membranes rupture, potassium is leached from the crop residue by rain water. So, how does incorporation of crop residues influence its nutrient value? The nutrient present in largest amounts in crop residue is potassium, and it will leach from residue as it rains, and then is loosely held on the Cation Exchange Complex of the soil (impacted by clay and humus%). Potassium availability or loss, therefore, is not likely to be affected by tillage. On the other hand, nitrogen and phosphorus release depend on crop residue decomposition by microbes, and this might be affected by incorporation, because decomposition is sped up. However, microorganisms use carbon in crop residue for energy and formation of cellular structures, and N and P are subsequently combined with C to build their bodies. Now the ratio of C:N and C:P in crop residue is higher than what microbes need – so they will pull available N and P from the soil instead of releasing it. Therefore, we can expect there to be an immobilization of N and P in the short term until the C:N and C:P ratios are brought into balance again when C escapes from the soil as carbon dioxide generated by cellular respiration. 

If residue is left on the soil surface, immobilization can be expected to be more gradual because the microbes decomposing residues are not in close contact with the soil. Although N and P release dynamics are affected by tillage, the total amounts released are not expected to be. Nonetheless, if tillage increases soil erosion, it does affect nutrient losses. Let’s assume a deep soil is eroding at ‘Tolerable’ Level of 5 T/A, and the total N, P and K contents are 0.2%, 0.1% and 0.2%, then we are losing 20 lbs/A of N, 13 lbs of P2O5 and 24 lbs of K2O equivalent in nutrients. In a nutshell, then, residue incorporation does not improve the nutrient value of crop residue or its release dynamics, and can instead, increase nutrient losses if it increases soil erosion.

Reference: 

USDA-NRCS, 2013. Economics Technical Note No. 3. USDA-NRCS Colorado, May 3, 2013.