Access Road Improvements for Practical and Water Quality Benefits
Considering Erosion
Water erosion happens when water flowing over the ground wears away soil or other materials from the Earth's surface. There are many factors involved in determining why a surface erodes. The amount of water, the slope's length and steepness, and the surface material all contribute to the likelihood that a surface, such as a driveway or other access road, will erode.
Access roads are considered impervious surfaces. Whether the gravel was compacted intentionally at the time of placement or by vehicle traffic over time, the surface is nearly impossible for water to soak into. Consequently, when it rains, most of the water that falls onto a driveway becomes stormwater runoff that may carry away part of your access lane along with it.

Roads tend to concentrate and carry runoff. Things like ruts, a sunken roadbed, and ditches are all things that lead to concentrated flow paths. The longer water flows down a roadway, the more likely it is to cause erosion problems because more water collects on the surface and it spends more time running downhill, gaining speed along the way (Figure 2). Steeper roadways will result in faster-flowing runoff. In general, water becomes more powerful the faster and deeper it flows, which means the potential for erosion increases further with longer, more intense storms. Bottom line, the longer and/or steeper the driveway is, the greater the potential for erosion when water uses it as its path for flowing downhill.
The surface material itself also impacts erodibility. Most aggregates used to surface driveways are a mixture of gravel, sand, silt, and clay-sized rock particles that often range in size from about two inches and smaller. Generally, smaller particles are less resistant to erosive forces of flowing water, whereas larger particles can generally withstand greater forces. However, particle size is not solely important when considering the durability of a surface. The ability to compact the aggregate material is critical for ensuring materials stay in place – water doesn’t penetrate, and the shape of the driving surface is maintained. Therefore, a mixture of well-graded particle sizes is preferable to simply selecting larger stone because it creates a surface that is both durable and compactable, which means it is less likely to erode, not to mention more pleasant to drive on. Aggregates that contain soil, organic materials, and clay are more likely to break down over time and cause issues such as ruts, dust, erosion, and sedimentation compared to aggregates primarily composed of crushed stone.
Solutions for Addressing Access Road Erosion
While we cannot control how much or when it rains, there are many ways to reduce the impact water has on our access roads. The Penn State Center for Dirt and Gravel Road Studies has done a great deal of research on preventing sediment and dust production from unpaved roads, and many of the concepts and solutions can be applied to household driveways, farm lanes, and other access roads as well. The most basic ideas behind improving access roads to ensure they are stable and reduce their impact on nearby waterways are to avoid concentrating runoff on or around the road, minimize the volume of water flowing on the road or in ditches, reduce the impact of any concentrated water flows, and prevent surface erosion on and around the access road. There are a variety of ways to approach these concepts, and the following factors can help determine which solution might address erosion problems on access roads.
The Shape of the Road Surface
A road surface shape that sheds water is the first line of defense against erosion. Does your driveway have a nice crown, slope to one side, or have ruts or dips where cars have driven day after day? Water flows downhill and follows the easiest path, which means if repeated traffic has formed depressions along the entire length of the driveway, the water will become trapped in the ruts and create more and more problems over time. Ideally, our roadways would either have a crown or be sloped to one side or the other. This directs water that falls onto a driveway, off it, and into an adjacent field or lawn, allowing the road to shed water rather than concentrate it. In general, the cross slope should be about 4 to 6 percent, meaning that there should be roughly ½ to ¾ inch of fall per foot across the roadway.Â
The Elevation of the Access Road
Roadways that have sunken below the natural elevation of the landscape will trap water on the roadway, rather than allowing it to dissipate into the surrounding landscape. This will concentrate runoff and is likely to worsen erosion and entrenchment problems over time. Access roads may be entrenched due to poor design, compaction from traffic, maintenance, and erosion. Raising the road profile with fill material so that the elevation more closely resembles the natural topography and the downslope side of the road is level with or slightly above the adjacent terrain will promote sheet flow from the road and allow for the installation of the drainage features where additional water movement is needed. When raising the road profile, fill material should be applied in layers no deeper than 8 inches at a time and well compacted before adding another layer. This will help prevent unintended ruts in the future. Raising the road profile provides a long-term solution to many drainage problems by eliminating at least one parallel ditch, restoring a more natural drainage pattern, reducing concentrated flow, and providing cover and opportunities to install drainage features such as cross pipes and belt diversions.
In some cases, the access road may not be entrenched, but a berm may have formed along the roadway, either intentionally or unintentionally, due to traffic or maintenance activities. Berms can trap and concentrate runoff in a way similar to entrenched roadways, causing accelerated erosion of the road surface. If your access lane or driveway has a berm, removing berm material with earthmoving equipment can allow runoff to flow off the road surface and disperse into the downslope terrain.
Length of the Slope
Shortening the distance that water continuously travels downhill can make a big difference in preventing erosion on long or steep slopes. While simply shortening the total length of an access road is typically impractical, there are a variety of ways we can reduce the distance water travels downhill without compromising its actual length. By diverting water off of the roadway and to a stabilized ditch or outlet before it reaches the bottom of the hill, we can effectively shorten the length of roadway that water continuously travels on. There are a few different techniques that can be used to shorten the area contributing runoff that could be used on private access roads:
- Grade breaks are intentional increases in road elevation or a change in the road grade to create rolling slopes along a long, continual section. These incremental elevation increases force water off the road surface into stabilized outlets or ditches, effectively shortening the contributing distance that water is flowing downhill at one time. Grade breaks are intended to direct sheet flow, rather than carry concentrated flow across a road. They are considered an inexpensive solution to addressing long slopes that are both easy to install and maintain on infrequently maintained roads with a gentle to moderate slope (less than 10 percent). Grade breaks create a speed bump-like division across a road profile so are effective solutions on driveways, farm lanes, and access roads where drivers use low speeds.
- Broad-based dips are installed by simultaneously excavating a dip in the road profile while also placing fill material below the dip to create a pathway for water to flow across the road surface on roadways with low traffic. While broad-based dips are similar to grade breaks in that they both separate a long, continual slope, grade breaks are meant to shed sheet flow towards the road shoulder, whereas broad-based dips are intended to carry a concentrated flow of water across the road surface (Figure 3). Consequently, broad-based dips function more similarly to cross pipes but are inexpensive, easy to install, and require less maintenance. Broad-based dips can be installed on road grades up to 10 percent and can be placed in sequence depending on the road's length and grade. They should be angled across the road at approximately 20 to 40 degrees and should have an elevation drop of at least 3 percent, directing water to a stabilized outlet. Rip rap may be needed at the outlet to dissipate energy and prevent erosion.
- Conveyor belt diversions are structures made from used conveyor belt that is bolted to treated lumber and partially buried in the road to divert water off the road surface. They can be installed on roadways that have lost their crown or side slope, provided that at least 4 inches of belt are exposed above the road surface (Figure 4). Belt diversions do not deform under heavy hauling, and they are particularly useful on access roads that have little, slow-moving traffic. Often, used conveyor belts can be acquired at little or no cost. Belt diversions are an inexpensive, easy-to-install and maintain, long-lasting solution on low-maintenance roadways. As with previously mentioned solutions, belt diversions can be installed in sequence, depending on the length of slope, road gradient, surface material stability, and amount of runoff. Belt diversions should be installed in a trench that is dug at least at a 30 percent angle across the roadway and should have at least 1 percent continuous fall towards the outlet. After placing the belt diversion, the trench should be backfilled and well compacted using a vibratory plate or jumping jack compactor to stabilize the material and prevent washouts. Large stones can be placed on the outlet side of the diversion to prevent unintended erosion.Â
- Shallow cross pipes. For access roads with a parallel ditch on the upslope side, culvert pipes can be installed across the roadway to carry water under the road surface (Figure 5). Shallow cross pipes are different than traditional pipes because they are placed at the natural ground elevation, and fill is imported and placed on top to provide adequate cover above the original road elevation. Shallow cross pipes eliminate the need for a tail ditch, which often needs continual maintenance. Additionally, importing material and placing it on top of the pipe effectively creates a grade break to help disperse surface runoff across the top of the road. As with other drainage structures, ensure the outlet is stable. Rip rap can be used to dissipate energy and prevent erosion.



Subsurface Drainage
Sometimes access roads are located in wet areas that intercept subsurface flow. Perpetually wet conditions caused by wetlands, springs, or seeps can expedite road degradation and contribute to excess erosion if left unaddressed. Practices such as underdrains and French drains can be used to collect and transport subsurface water from springs and seeps. A larger French Mattress can be installed in extremely wet areas, like wetlands and areas with high water tables, to support the roadbed while also allowing subsurface water movement through the profile. These practices use materials like perforated pipe, large clean stone, and geotextile fabric to create a pathway for subsurface water to flow while reducing its impact on the roadway.
Surface materials
Gravel is often placed on driveways and access roads with the expectation that it will wash away over time. This movement of gravel and sediment is not only costly but also threatens streams and other water bodies. Addressing drainage issues and thoughtfully selecting surface materials can go a long way in preventing erosion and the need for continual resurfacing. In some cases, like dirt access roads to farm fields, improving drainage by ensuring water can effectively run off roadways may be enough to prevent accelerated erosion. In many cases, a more finished surface may be desired, so considering the quality of the surface aggregate can be beneficial.Â
There are two major things to consider when selecting an aggregate: the material itself and the gradation, or size distribution, of the material. Typically, good surface aggregates are made primarily of crushed stone of varying sizes. The material should be blocky, angular, resistant to breakdown, and free of debris. While a small amount of clay may be desirable in drier regions, surface aggregates should generally be free from soil, organic matter, and clay (in wet or cold climates).  Good-quality surface aggregates should also have a well-graded size distribution, meaning a broad spectrum of particle sizes, so they can be compacted and are resistant to erosion and wear. For roadways primarily used by passenger vehicles, such as driveways, a 1.5-inch maximum size is typically desirable. For access roads that are more commonly used by large equipment, stone with a larger gradation, up to 4 inches, can be used to create a more stable driving surface (Figure 6). Regardless of which maximum-sized stone is desirable, the selected aggregate should also contain a well-distributed mix of smaller stones, including at least 10 percent microscopic silt, rock dust, or clay to aid compaction.
In addition to selecting good material, many preparation steps are critical to improve the longevity of an aggregate. Ruts or potholes should be graded out (Figure 7), any new drainage features should be installed, and the crown or cross slope should be established prior to placing a new aggregate. Surface material should be placed evenly in order to maintain the underlying road shape (Figure 8). When aggregate is applied, it should have adequate moisture and be placed to a sufficient depth so that it can be successfully compacted (Figure 9).




Conclusion
Maintaining farm lanes, access roads, or driveways often requires more than just spreading gravel from time to time. Taking a look at where erosion is happening and how water flows on and around your access road will provide clues to what practices may help provide longer-term solutions. For more detailed explanations of the practices listed in this article, refer to the United States Forest Service's Environmentally Sensitive Road Maintenance Practices for Dirt and Gravel Roads or the Penn State Center for Dirt and Gravel Road Studies technical bulletins. Pennsylvania's Agriculture Conservation Assistance Program supports Pennsylvania farmers and agricultural landowners in their efforts to protect and enhance water quality. Farms across Pennsylvania that are interested in receiving technical or financial assistance for farm lane improvements on their operations can reach out to their County Conservation District ACAP Technician for assistance or Penn State Extension's Center for Ag Conservation Assistance Training.
References
DCNR Bureau of Forestry DSA/Aggregate, Penn State Center for Dirt and Gravel Road Studies, 2021
Reviewed by Jacob Tomlinson, Ag Conservation Educator, Penn State Extension Center for Agriculture Conservation Assistance Training, and Tyler Groh, Watershed Management Extension Specialist, Penn State Extension











