Lameness' Domino Effect
Posted: June 7, 2012
As I visit dairy farms across Pennsylvania in my role as a Penn State Dairy Extension Team member, two dairy cow health related problems persist on many of the farms, lameness and delayed pregnancies due to various reproductive issues.
According to an eXtension article updated on January 27, 2011, studies completed in the state of New York have shown lameness to cost $90 per cow/ year on average. Interestingly, the review of an article written by John F. Smith (1999), Extension Dairy Specialist, New Mexico State University, suggests that a delay in pregnancy of 30 days may result in a loss of $90 per cow/year, based on a loss of $3.00 per cow per day for open cows beyond 90 days post calving.
Can lameness ($90 per cow/year) add to reproductive problems ($90 per cow/year) in dairy herds we are working with, resulting in a multiplying effect on loss to profitability? In the proceedings of the 2011 Dairy Cattle Reproduction Council’s annual meeting, Dr. Jeffrey Defrain, Dr. Michael Socha, and Dr. Dana Tomlinson, Zinpro Inc., present a review of several research articles that provides an answer to this question. Here are some of the major conclusions they cited from studies conducted on this topic:
al. (1986) found that lameness was associated with a longer interval between
calving and first service breedings. The largest increase (17 and 30 days)
occurred in cows with either sole or white line lesions that were occurring in
early lactation. The study also found that conception rates were lower in lame
cows (31%) compared to other healthy cows (40%).
More recent work by Hedandez et al. (2005) found lameness increased the time period from calving to conception 3 times greater than the estimates initially reported by Lucey et al (1986).
Speicher et al. (1997) examined data for cows scoring 3 or higher on the 5 point dairy cow locomotion scoring system. These cows were 2.8 times more likely to have increased days to first service, 15.6 times more likely to have increased days open and 9.0 times more likely to have increased services per conception. These cows were also 8.4 times more likely to be culled from the herd.
Hernandez et al. (2000) found cows with abscesses/sole ulcers were open 63 days longer than healthy cows exhibiting no lameness issues.
Melandez et al. (2003) showed that cows clinically lame due to a claw disorder in the first 30 days post calving had a 58.9 % decrease in first service conception rate and an increase in the incidence of ovarian cysts.
With these studies in mind, it is apparent that dairy producers should deal promptly with dairy cow lameness, not only because of the economic losses due directly to lameness issues, but also because of the economic losses due indirectly to lameness as it relates to increased days open and other reproduction factors. Information about lameness can be found at http://www.healthyhooves.com/pdffiles/dr%20shearer.pdf.
- By Gary Hennip, Extension educator, Penn State Extension Dairy Team, firstname.lastname@example.org, 570-265-2896